|
Gentleman's Agreement (1947)
In producer Darryl F. Zanuck's and director Elia Kazan's
serious, preachy Best Picture-winning social drama - a landmark film
- and an historically-significant and tough expose of post-war anti-Semitism:
- the introduction of the topic of anti-Semitism,
in a breakfast scene, when recently-widowed, crusading, non-Jewish
(Gentile) magazine writer Phil "Schuyler" Green (Gregory
Peck) spoke to his innocent young son Tommy (Dean Stockwell) about
prejudiced anti-Semite sentiment: "Oh, that's where some people
don't like other people just because they're Jews"; when Tommy
pressed: "Why? Are they bad?", he added: "Well,
some are, sure and some aren't, it's just like everybody else";
ultimately, Phil couldn't really explain the reason for the hatred;
shortly later, Tommy was taunted and assaulted by his playmates,
who believed he was Jewish
- the scene of novelist Phil speaking to his live-in
mother Mrs. Green (Ann Revere) in their NYC apartment about how he
was struggling with the approach to his next writing assignment for
a national magazine known as Smith's Weekly; the expose would
be about anti-Semitism; his idea was to try and capture the feelings
of his long-time Jewish childhood friend Dave Goldman (John Garfield)
on paper: ("Can I think my way into Dave's mind? He's the kind
of fellow I'd be if I were a Jew, isn't he?...Whatever Dave feels
now - indifference, outrage, contempt - would be the feelings of
Dave not only as a Jew but the way I feel as a man, as an American,
as a citizen. Is that right, Ma?...Hey, maybe I've broken this log
jam, Ma, maybe this is it?") - but then he realized as he sat
at his typewriter: ("There isn't any way you can tear open the
secret heart of another human being")
- in a breakthrough with his mother, Phil's decision
to adopt an unorthodox approach in order to gather truthful material
(in an unbiased way) for a series of articles ("I Was Jewish
for Six Months"): he would assume a Jewish identity as Phil
Greenberg for six months to experience at first hand discrimination
and anti-Semitism: "I can just tell them I am and see what happens....Dark
hair, dark eyes. Sure, so has Dave. So have a lot of guys who aren't
Jewish. No accent, no mannerisms. Neither has Dave."
- Phil's discussion with his bothered secretary Elaine
Wales (June Havoc) (who was Jewish herself, but had changed her name
from Estelle Walovsky to obtain employment); she couldn't believe
that he was willing to give up his 'Christian' identity for eight
weeks for the sake of a story, and he defended himself: ("Face
me, now Miss Wales. Come on, now look at me. Same face, same eyes,
same nose, same suit, same everything. Here. Take my hand. Feel it!
Same flesh as yours, isn't it? No different today than it was yesterday,
Miss Wales. The only thing that's different is the word Christian");
at one point, she described how even Smith's Weekly ("The
great liberal magazine that fights injustice on all sides")
revealed its own anti-Semite prejudice to her when she applied for
a position; he also politely reprimanded her for using prejudiced
words: "Now look, Miss Wales, we've got to be frank with each
other. You have a right to know right now that words like yid and
kike and kikey and nigger and coon make me kind of sick no matter
who says them"
- the confrontational scene of his checking into a high-class
luxury hotel where it was suspected that Phil was Jewish (from his
name) - the manager (Morgan Farley) directly asked: "In answer
to your question. May I inquire, are you? - That is, uh, do you follow
the Hebrew religion yourself, or is it that you just want to make
sure?" - and then announced that there were no vacancies and
refused to answer Phil's direct and simple questions about his bias
on restricting guest clientele to Gentiles: ("Look, I'm Jewish
and you don't take Jews - that's it, isn't it?...If you don't accept
Jews, say so!...Do you or don't you?")
- the arrival of Phil's Jewish friend Dave Coleman to
temporarily live with Phil while looking for work, and Dave's reaction
to the impact that Phil's effective yet unorthodox impersonation
of being Jewish was having: "You crazy fool. And it's working?...You're
not insulated yet, Phil. It's new every time so the impact must be
quite a business on you!"; Phil responded: "You mean you
get indifferent to it in time?"; Dave answered: "No, but
you're concentrating a lifetime thing into a few weeks. You're making
the thing happen every day, going out to meet it. The facts are no
different, Phil, it just telescopes it, makes it hurt more"
|
|
Tense Words with Kathy Lacey About the
Pervasiveness of Anti-Semitism
|
- the scene of Phil's conclusion about the pervasiveness
of anti-Semitism among "good people" to his romantic
interest, divorced schoolteacher Kathy Lacey (Dorothy McGuire),
his publisher's niece, emphasizing that there was bigotry and prejucide
among even the "good" and "nice" people; Phil's
research caused slight tension between them when she told him: "You
really do think I'm an anti-Semite"; he replied: ("No,
it's just that I've come to see that lots of nice people who aren't,
people who despise it and detest it and deplore it, and protest
their own innocence, then help it along
and wonder why it grows. People who would never beat up a Jew,
a young kike or a child. People who think that anti-Semitism is
something away off in some dark crackpot place with low-class morons.
That's the biggest discovery I've made about this whole business.
The good people, the nice people")
|
Struggling Magazine Writer Phil Green with Mother
Decision to Assume Jewish Identity
Speaking to Secretary Elaine Wales
Rejected as Jew at Hotel
Dave: "You're concentrating a lifetime thing into
a few weeks"
|