|
Bigger Than Life (1956)
In this insightful Nicholas Ray Eisenhower-Era melodrama
about the family - a superb critique of the suffocating and claustrophobic
conformity of 50s middle-class life (a film pre-dating American
Beauty (1999) by over 40 years!), and an examination of prescription
drug abuse:
- the character of ill, underpaid and frustrated schoolteacher
and middle-class family man Ed Avery (James Mason), who - after
severe blackouts and other symptoms, was being treated with an
experimental 'wonder drug' (cortisone) for his severe illness
(periarteritis nodosa - a destructive inflammation of the arteries)
- the sequence of his release from the hospital, when
he was dropped off at school by his long-suffering, beleaguered and
loving wife Lou (Barbara Rush), as he boasted exuberantly: "When
I came down into the hospital lobby and saw you and Richie again,
I felt ten feet tall"
- the sequence of Ed standing in front of a cracked
medicine cabinet mirror - expressing how his tormented character
was about to go through increasingly-wild personality changes and
fractured mood swings due to prescription drug addiction
- the two scenes of Ed's manic, consumer spending spree
- a sign of his deterioration and developing megalomania and tyrannical
nature, when he took Lou shopping at an expensive ladies' clothing
shop in town; first, he denigrated the female clerk: "My wife
and I aren't used to places like this so it's only fair to tell you,
that if we don't get a whole lot of high-class service - and in a
hurry, there's likely to be a terribly embarrassing scene in this
sanctum"; during the dress-buying, he sat nearby with a cigarette
and imperiously directed everyone and non-chalantly purchased a very
expensive item; and then he also forced his pre-teen son Richie (Christopher
Olsen) to purchase an expensive bike
- the scene of Ed's offensive and haughty criticisms
of every tenent of 50s life - including his deliberate rant-filled
denouncement of the school and its failed educational policies during
a PTA meeting where the walls displayed children's artwork: ("Every
year whole forests are cut down to supply the paper for these grotesque
daubs. And we coo over them as though they were Van Goghs or Rembrandts....Childhood
is a congenital disease and the purpose of education is to cure it.
I see my point of view is new to many of you. But ask yourselves,
how do we describe the unfortunate individual who carries his unspoiled
childhood instincts into adult life? We say he's arrested. We call
him a moron. (Parents gasped, one with a daughter named Louise)...
My dear lady, your Louise is a charming little creature, but we must
try to examine the problem without prejudice or sentiment. The hard
fact remains that your daughter, at her present stage of development,
is roughly on an intellectual par with the African gorilla. (More
gasps).... What, after all, from the Stone Age to the present day
has been the greatest invention of mankind? Has anybody got a match?...(He
lit his cigarette) Fire? The wheel? Safety pin? The hydrogen bomb?
No, ladies and gentlemen, the alphabet. And persons like myself are
required to teach these poor, bewildered kids to read by a system
of word recognition as though the mighty English language were a
collection of Chinese ideograms. And then we're surprised when Junior
can't even wade through the comics...."The three Rs" -
that's just a catchphrase. Before it's too late, we ought to get
back to the real fundamentals. And I'm not just talking of
primary education now. We're breeding a race of moral midgets. (Even
more gasps) All this hogwash about 'self-expression', 'permissiveness',
'development patterns', 'emotional security'. Security - with the
world ready to blow up. If the republic is to survive, we've got
to get back to teaching the good old virtues of hard work and self-discipline
and a sense of duty! My friends, I tell you, we're committing hara-kiri
every day right here in this classroom")
Dysfunctional Family Life
|
|
|
|
Criticisms During Football Catch With Son Richie
|
Belittling Son During Math Homework
|
"Our marriage is over"
|
- the sequence of Ed's frenzied outdoor game of football
catch with Richie even after he became totally exhausted, and his
negative criticisms: "What did you close your eyes for? You
can't expect to catch a pass with your eyes closed!"
- the scene in which the increasingly pushy, fragmented
and opinionated Ed constantly belittled and tyrannized his son Richie
during home-schooling - with his disciplining presence (and dark
black shadow) towering over him, in a low-angle shot, during a mathematics
lesson late at night
- the dinner scene at a long table in which he told
his wife Lou that their marriage was over: ("Our marriage is
over. In my mind, I've divorced you. You're not my wife any longer,
and I'm not your husband any longer") although he remained in
the house "solely for the boy's sake"
- the scene of Ed's worried son locking himself in
the bathroom in order to call his father's doctor, Dr. Norton (Robert
F. Simon) to stop his prescription: ("And I'm going to call
Dr. Norton to make you stop taking those pills. I don't care if your
pain does come back. I'd rather you were dead than the way you are
now")
- the dramatic scene of Ed reading from the Bible (following
the text with a knife in his hand) and his determination to emulate
Abraham's sacrifice of his son Isaac in the Old Testament: ("And
Abraham built an altar there and laid the wood in order, and bound
Isaac his son and laid him on the altar upon the wood. And Abraham
stretched forth his hand and took the knife to slay his son")
- when Lou reminded him that God aborted the sacrifice and saved
Isaac at the last minute ("But Ed, you didn't read it all. God
stopped Abraham") - but Ed replied with an emphatic declaration
to his wife: "God was wrong!"
- after being returned to the hospital for further treatment,
in the film's final sequence around his bed, Ed seemed to have been
relieved of his psychosis; he described a dream he just had: "I
was dreaming. I walked with Lincoln. He was as big and ugly and beautiful
as he was in life. Abraham. Abraham!" - he then turned to his
son with worry about what he had done to him: "Did I hurt you?
I tried to. Are you all right?"; Richie responded:
"I'm all right, Dad"; Ed responded: "I remember now.
I remember everything that happened"; Dr. Norton reassured him: "That's
the way it should be, Ed"
- the film ended with Ed intensely hugging his family
and asking for them to be "closer"; Lou joked: "Ed,
you'll have us both in bed," but Ed repeated his desperate request:
"That's what I mean. Closer. Closer"
|
Ed Avery: "I Feel Ten Feet Tall"
Metaphoric Cracked Bathroom Cabinet Mirror
Manic Shopping Spree At the Dress Shop
Ed's Rant at The PTA Meeting
Richie Calling the Doctor For His Father's Condition
With Knife in Hand - Re-enacting Abraham's Sacrifice of
Isaac
A Happy Ending? - "Closer" in Bed and
Hugging
|